There was a man living inside Tyler’s oven. He was covered head to foot in soot and grime, but his eyes shone through—bright green. Every night after Tyler was asleep, the man would crawl, painfully due to his height, out of the oven, and walk into Tyler’s room. He would wake Tyler by gently tapping his shoulder three times. Each night had a story, and each story had a moral. Tyler tried his best to take them all to heart, diligently recording everything in a black notebook, which he kept under the bed. In the mornings, on the drive into work, Tyler would review the previous night’s story in his mind. It was like a small light inside, guiding him through the suffering of the coming day.
Tyler worked at a body farm. He was a janitor, of sorts, keeping the vultures away from the corpses and picking up stray garbage that blew into the enclosure. The bodies looked like bad props baking in the sun—orange and strangely hairy. It was difficult for him to imagine they had once been people.
When Tyler wasn’t working he was alone in his apartment, watching Star Trek: the Next Generation and drinking IPAs. The window over his kitchen sink displayed the back of a corrugated metal church. On Sunday mornings he would awake to acoustic praise anthems drifting up through the floorboards. Tyler didn’t believe in God but prayed hard all the time, mostly just little things to get through the day. He felt as if he’d been blind before he’d met the man in the oven.
Over time the man’s stories grew longer. The morals became more complex. Some nights the lesson would stretch on until four or five in the morning. Tyler would patiently jot everything down in the notebook. The more he learned, the more his own life appeared arbitrary, as if he was watching a stranger go about their day.
Emptying the trash cans and medical bins into bigger receptacles. Powerwashing the fence. A hazy view of bodies rotting under the sun, a can of Coke Zero poured into a red solo cup at the lunch table—everything Tyler saw looked the same. Only the stories meant anything to him. Only the stories were real.
Besides a word here or there to coworkers, the only person Tyler ever spoke to was his mom. On the third Tuesday of every month she would phone in from central Ohio to talk about casserole recipes and the Methodist church. Tyler listened quietly, feeling far away. It was hard to believe that he had sprung forth from this woman’s sex life. What a joke.
As the days grew colder and the stories grew longer, he started to lie more and more to his mother. He told her that he had found God. He told her that he had found a girlfriend. He knew what she wanted to hear, so it was easy to know what to say. The amorphous shame he had carried around his entire life eased.
The night before the winter solstice the man in the oven told Tyler that there would be no story that night. Instead he was going to show him something.
“What is it?” asked Tyler.
“The truth,” said the man, and flashed a set of yellowing teeth.
“What is truth?” asked Tyler, thinking the man would enjoy this clever remark.
“You’re about to find out.”
The man led Tyler to the oven, swung the door open, and pulled out the wire trays. He hopped inside and unscrewed a metal panel in the back. It popped open to reveal a blackened crawl shaft. Tyler felt afraid, and said so. The man laughed and motioned for Tyler to follow him. Tyler watched as the man disappeared into the tunnel. It felt as though his whole life had led up to this moment. Dutifully, he plunged inside, ears straining to follow the sounds of the man up ahead.
The floor scraped against Tyler’s belly as he crawled through total darkness. It was humid and hard to breathe. His elbows and fingers became raw. Just when he thought he couldn’t bear it, they popped out of a wall panel and into a carpeted, octagonal hallway. Tyler blinked. Fluorescent lights on the ceiling strained his eyes.
“Welcome aboard!” the man said.
Tyler got back on his feet. Rectangular windows dotted the walls, displaying what was unmistakably outer space. Tiny stars like millions of pin pricks dotted the blackness. The hallway felt familiar, like something from a recurring dream. The man motioned Tyler to keep following. He stumbled down the winding hallway, the man farther ahead than ever. They passed through automatic doors with nameplates above them. The plaques said things like “Peanut Butter” and “Business and Finance.” They continued on past doors emblazoned with strange symbols. They climbed across digital circuitry and pulsing neon tubes. At every corner, Tyler feared he would lose sight of the man.
Eventually they came to an ornate, brightly colored door, like a giant playing card stood on its end. The man from the oven was beaming and leaning against it.
“Are you ready for your lesson?”
“I’m not sure. Do you think I can handle it?”
“I know you can handle it because you’re like me. You seek out the truth. Most people only seek out comfortable lies.”
He loved it when the man complimented him. He thought of his mother for a few seconds, and then nodded towards the door. The man pushed it open in a grand sweeping gesture.
It revealed a wide, dark room filled with control panels and plush chairs. Backlit neon buttons silhouetted giant insects at their work stations. A huge viewscreen mounted seamlessly to the wall showed Earth from outer space. With a start, Tyler realized that he was standing in a replica of the bridge from The Next Generation. He balled his hands into fists but made no sound. Everything was still for a few minutes as they watched the insects work.
A centipede waddled over to the far side of the room and made itself busy at a set of controls. A light blue hologram of earth whizzed into existence at the center of the bridge. Immediately all the other bugs abandoned their posts and scurried towards it, scuttling over each other in excitement. The centipede flipped some more switches and the teal globe became dotted with clusters of red. Tiny geo-mapped points stacked on top of each other to form amorphous shapes. It looked like digital acne.
The insects clicked in anticipation, shoving and pushing each other aside. Wispy trails of luminescent, blue-green smoke flowed from the red regions of the Earth to the gathered insects. They whirred in ecstasy, the smoke curling into their undersides. A cockroach the size of a horse flipped on its back, straining with pleasure as the smoke filled its belly.
Tyler watched from the corner, his heart beating fast but his mind oddly blank.
“It’s like water to them,” said the man from the oven, “or like if water was also sex. They need it to live.”
“Need what to live?” asked Tyler.
“Suffering,” said the man. “They mine it from the earth—from the animals and the people that live there.”
Tyler nodded, externally calm.
“So this is it then?” he asked. “The truth?”
The man shrugged. “Pretty much.”
“And where do you fit into all of this?”
“I’m just a guy with a bad job.”
The oven man spit into his palm and dragged it across his face. He repeated this several times until a good portion of the muck and ash came off. He looked up at Tyler, his face partially visible for the first time.
“Do you understand now?” the man asked.
The insects were still feeding when the two men left. Tyler stumbled along behind the man for ages. They crawled back through the oven at dawn.
“I’m going to live here, inside your house now,” the man said, grabbing a towel from the dryer.
Tyler said nothing and headed for his room. He locked the door and fell asleep immediately.
He awoke around sunset the next day and stumbled to the kitchen to make some coffee. The man from the oven was already there, making an elaborate sandwich. He had showered, shaved, and cut his hair. He stood at the kitchen counter, an exact replica of Tyler, humming to himself as he halved and sliced an avocado.
“Hey there sleeping beauty,” said the man. “Good dreams?”
Tyler grunted. There was already coffee in the pot, long cold. He poured himself a mug full.
“I forgot to call out of work,” mumbled Tyler between sips of coffee.
“Oh don’t worry! I took care of it for you.”
“What are you talking about?” asked Tyler.
“Oh relax. No one even noticed.”
The man slid an extra slice of tomato under the top piece of bread and took a bite. “We’re going to be sharing a lot more things, you and I,” he said and smiled, mouth full of sandwich.
Tyler was too tired to protest. He stumbled to the bathroom to take a piss. While washing his hands he caught a glimpse of himself in the mirror. He was covered in a considerable amount of muck from the crawlspace. In a daze, he stumbled out looking for fresh towels. They were all piled on top of the washer, covered in black streaks.
“I’ll get to those soon!” said the man brightly.
Tyler grabbed a roll of paper towels and hit the shower.
The hot steam irritated his skin and his breath felt shallow. He began to cough deep in his chest, spitting out chunks of mucus and dirt. He scrubbed and scrubbed away at his flesh, but when he came out and looked in the mirror, it was hard to tell the difference. He dried off with the paper towels. They scraped unpleasantly against his skin. It felt pointless to change into new, clean clothes when he was filthy as ever underneath, so he put the dirty clothes from the previous night back on. When he returned to the kitchen, his new roommate was gone and there was a note taped to the counter: “Going out. Don’t wait up.”
Tyler opened the fridge. It was empty save for IPAs and mustard. He took out an IPA, cracked it open, and walked to the living room. He put on Star Trek: the Next Generation. The first episode was about Data making a daughter for himself. The second was about Worf avenging his father. Tyler fell asleep during the one about Worf.
Tyler woke late again the next day, his stomach burning with hunger. He wandered back to the kitchen but found nothing new in the fridge. The note from last night had been replaced by a new one: “Went to work.”
His car was gone, wallet too. He manically searched his apartment for loose cash. Finding only a few dollars, and fearing the light of day, Tyler instead settled on a can of chickpeas, a holdover from a New Year’s resolution to cook more. He ate them cold from the can, feeling like an animal, and pausing only to gulp water straight from the sink. Once finished he collapsed into a kitchen chair.
Tyler felt as if he might cry, something he hadn’t done in years. He thought better of it and called his mom instead.
“Hello?” she said hesitantly. He never called beyond their monthly talk.
“Hey, is this a bad time?”
There was silence on the other end.
“Mom? Are you there?”
“Tyler, it is you! You sound horrible, honey. Are you sick?”
“Yes, Ma. I’m sick.”
“And that’s why you’re not at work?”
“Mom, I’m calling because I’m really not doing well.”
“Sweetie, please just lie down and get some rest! I’m at my job. Can I call you back later?”
“Sure,” said Tyler, feeling farther away than usual. “No problem.”
The next day Tyler woke up on the couch again. It was morning and blinding light ambushed him from all angles. Beer bottles littered the floor around his feet—the very last of the IPAs. The Next Generation was still playing on the TV. Captain Picard was naked and being tortured by Cardassians.
Tyler heard commotion in the kitchen: the sound of a door being swung open. He dashed off the couch and caught the man right as he was exiting the apartment.
“Give me back my wallet,” Tyler shouted.
“Give me back my wallet,” the man parroted back nastily.
“I’ll call the police.”
“I’ll call the police. Just who do they think they’ll believe, you or me?” With that, he slammed the door shut.
Tyler was starving. He checked the fridge and found, to his surprise, a 12 pack of Miller Light with a sticky note that said, “For you.” He immediately cracked one open and searched the cupboards for more food. Finding nothing, he cracked open a second beer.
Manic and pacing, he grabbed the unwashed knife from the counter, the one the man used to make sandwiches. He stood holding it in front of the mirror for a while, picturing stabbing it again and again into his doppleganger’s brain. He pictured the blood all over the floor, pictured the look of panic on the man’s face as the blade went in, pictured having to bury his own identical body. His thoughts disturbed him. It was a guilty fantasy, and whatever joy it gave him was rapidly drying up and being replaced by fear. He dropped the knife. He was hopeless.
Whenever Tyler felt like this, he knew where to turn. As quietly as he could, he pushed the door to his room open. After only two nights on the couch, the room already felt unfamiliar, its usual state of disarray replaced by a deliberate neatness. It didn’t matter. It wasn’t why he was here. Gingerly, Tyler hunched down and fished the black notebook out from under the bed. Just the familiar weight of it made him feel better immediately. He kissed it softly, breathing in its scent.
Tyler triumphantly shuffled back to the couch, carefully shutting the bedroom door on his way out. He ran his fingers along the spine of the notebook, breath quickening in anticipation. He flipped open to the first page. He scanned it eagerly but his careful notes were gone, replaced by some sort of incomprehensible gibberish. He blinked down at the alien script, eyes bulging. He turned the page again: more gibberish. At first he thought that someone had swapped out his precious notebook for a copy. However, upon further inspection, Tyler found that it was, in fact, English. He even recognized his own handwriting in the sloppy O’s and lopsided W’s. Each letter was exhausting to decipher. Every word was a mountain to climb, and by the end of each sentence he had forgotten the start. There was nothing to glean here.
He let the notebook fall to the floor. The ceiling light pulsed, a blinding sun. His eyes hurt. His skin crawled. He whimpered strangely and turned off the light. There in the dark, Tyler ripped out and ate the first few pages from the notebook. The paper turned to sod in his mouth and it was hard to swallow. Unpleasant as it was, he felt that the pages must have some power remaining. If he couldn’t read, maybe he could ingest. His eyes began to adjust to the darkness. His fingernails lengthened, his teeth sharpened against his tongue. He laughed for the first time in—weeks? Months?
When he was done, the notebook cover sat empty, the pages a part of him now. He felt comforted but not altogether right. He crawled around the apartment for hours, rubbing his belly on the floor and scratching various itches in his head.
When it all got to be too much, he went back to the TV. Tyler drank and watched Star Trek the rest of the day, gripping the kitchen knife at his side just in case. The show didn’t make sense to him anymore, but he still squinted at the shapes. He knew the characters but it was like every word they said was distorted: a message shouted across a river. Hours passed and his eyelids got heavy from the alcohol. His vision faded to black as Counselor Troi advised Barclay on how to avoid social anxiety at parties. This was a bit that Tyler especially loved back when he had eyes to see it.
Tyler awoke in the dead of night to ecstatic screaming. A woman moaned with pleasure in the next room, while another giggled and egged somebody on.
“Is that all you got?” she cackled.
“I’ll show you what I got!” he heard a man roar. The sound of flesh slapping against flesh followed. Tyler felt as if he might vomit. Unspeakable sounds echoed through the apartment. He wanted to scream but feared any noise might put him in danger. He pictured three figures, stark naked and dripping fluids, racing out from the bedroom to grab him and drag him away. He couldn’t handle that. He pulled the knife out from where it had fallen between the cushions, and slinked towards the kitchen as quietly as possible. It was not the moment to strike and yet he felt he needed protection, a place to hide.
His gaze fell upon the oven, its door invitingly ajar. The wire racks were still on the floor from—how many days had it been now? He crawled over and squeaked the door completely open. Inside it was warm and dark, a welcoming alternative to life. He crawled inside and closed the door behind him. He had to jam his knees up to his head to fit, but the effect wasn’t unpleasant. It felt safe. In the oven the sounds were muted, indistinguishable from the general hum of the apartment. Feeling like a lizard, he licked his lips. Then—unexpectedly—he cried. It had been years.
Tyler awoke to the sound of whistling. It was to the tune of “Jingle Bells.” He coughed violently and crawled out of the oven onto the floor, knife still in hand.
The man stopped whistling. He was standing at the counter, back to the oven, making another sandwich.
“You almost cost me a good time yesterday. Not exactly a turn-on hearing you cry like a baby all night.”
Tyler murmured weakly, too tired to speak. He looked around.
“Oh, they’re gone now. Not exactly girlfriend material if you catch my drift.”
The sandwich looked amazing. Salivating, Tyler pointed at it expectantly.
“You can have food when you learn your place,” said the man, suddenly stern. “If I come back with guests I expect you to stay out of sight. None of this couch potato shit. And pick up your beer cans.”
Tyler nodded, compliant. He was still thinking of the sandwich.
“I’m throwing a holiday party this weekend,” the man said, “It’ll be with all of those coworkers you never bothered to talk to. I expect you to stay completely out of sight for the entirety of the festivities.”
“And where am I supposed to go?” Tyler managed, words cracking like gravel in his throat.
“And where am I supposed to go?” the man repeated back. “I think you know.”
Tyler glanced down at the oven. His vision swam with the sight of it. The man turned to really look at Tyler. It was a humorous look, but not without pity.
“Boy do you look like shit.”
“I look like you,” said Tyler.
At this the man’s face clouded with anger. It bothered him because it was true. He turned his back to Tyler and slowly continued assembling his sandwich.
“I’m nothing like you,” the man said finally. “You’re a coward. You never dared to live even a single day of your life like you were alive.”
He slammed his fist against the counter and continued: “You miserable little shit, how I hated you. Night after night having to listen to you complaining. Having to tell you how special you were. Having to reassure your constantly wounded ego.”
Tyler’s face felt hot, but he couldn’t think of anything to say.
“I just couldn’t bear to see you waste your life anymore,” the man said, separating herbs. “Someone had to step in and enjoy the thing, even if it wasn’t going to be you.”
“Hark! The Herald Angel Sings” floated up from the corrugated metal church outside, the sound of it reverberating strangely.
“Can I ask you something?” Tyler said, gripping the kitchen knife at his side.
“Sure thing, Bud,” said the man, his back still turned, adjusting the pickles.
“All those things you used to tell me—the stories—were they really true?”
“Oh I don’t know,” said the man, shaking up a bottle of mustard. “What is truth?”
Tyler raised the knife and stabbed the man in the back. He withdrew the blade to stab again, but before he could, the man turned around and punched him in the face. Tyler fell back and dropped the knife in surprise. It slid across the floor.
Both men went for it. One got there first. The man with the knife stabbed the other in the chest. Blood pooled and slid all over the kitchen floor. Tiny rivers of red swam in the direction of the oven. “Silent Night” played through the window.
It was Christmas morning.
The following Monday, after the holiday, a man got to the body farm at the break of dawn. He unlocked the front gate, and dragged in a dark bundle wrapped in trash bags. He went to the far end of the enclosure and unwrapped the body, which tumbled out stiffly onto its back. Glassy eyes stared up at the circling buzzards. The man paced around the body. He kicked it nervously to make sure it was really dead, then kneeled down beside it. He stroked the corpse’s face with automatic hands, kissed it gently on the forehead, and finally closed its eyes. He reached into his coat pocket and placed a black noteback, pages all gone but frame intact, into the corpse’s fingers.
The man smiled. He said, “that’s better” a few times, then rolled the body over, face down in the dirt. He whistled “Away in a Manger” to himself and watched the sunrise. At the end of the month the body count was off by one, or maybe someone miscounted. This resulted in a few moments of tense conversation in the breakroom. The incident would, however, never be brought up to management. In a few months only bones would remain.
But that was another day. Today was a new day and it was going to be a long one. The man cracked his back and began to pick up garbage with a pointed stick. Miles away on someone’s TV set Data cried. He was learning how to be human.
